![](../images/header_cantmiss.gif)
Over
the past twenty years or so, the Dodgers have made a habit of prematurely
giving up on young talent, yet sticking with stiffs. To most fans,
it's usually quite obvious which of these "can't miss"
prospects really have any talent and which ones should immediately
be dumped into the sea. Yet, the Dodgers continually reject trade
proposals for the crappy ones, preferring instead to invest time
and energy into their futile development. Below are some of these
"can't miss" prospects... many of whom definitely missedor
made it big elsewhere.
»
Dodger debut:
1983
»
Finally given up on:
1985
»
The low-down:
Rivera was supposedly a good-glove third baseman who would allow
Pedro Guerrero to move back to the outfield. Rivera was the opening
day third baseman in '84. In 94 games that season, Rivera had 15
errors and just 17 RBIs. By the '85 season, he was gone.
»
Dodger debut:
1997
»
Finally given up on:
1998
»
The low-down:
Reyes was supposed to be the next coming of Fernando, and pysically
he was. But the similarities ended there. Reyes went 2-7 in limited
time with the Dodgers, and was traded just before the '98 all-star
break along with Paul Konerko to the Reds for Jeff Shaw. When a
guy is named after a 24-hour diner, you can't expect much from him.
»
Dodger debut:
1981
»
Finally given up on:
1989
»
The low-down:
In his eight seasons with the Dodgers, Marshall spent more time
complaining about hangnails than he did hitting. He posted careers
highs in 1985 with 28 HR and 95 RBI, but never really came close
to that in any other season. During his Dodger career, Marshall
fought with teammates and management, but somehow managed to hang
around for almost a decadea supposed savior who never lived
up to his "potential."
»
Dodger debut:
1998
»
Finally given up on:
2001
»
The low-down:
Pena, once the Los Angeles Dodgers' top catching prospect, frustrated
the Dodgers with his attitude and weight. He started the '99 season
with the team, but hit just .208. In July of '99 he was sent down
and subsequently suspended in August for "breaking a team rule."
While the Dodgers did not disclose the rule, we're guessing it was
"Don't eat the hitting coach." In 2000, Pena reported
to spring training at 262 pounds, and despite dropping 20, never
figured prominently in the Dodgers plans again.
»
Dodger debut:
1983
»
Finally given up on:
1988
»
The low-down:
Reyes was once thought of as a bright catching prospect, but the
organization eventually soured on him... after 5 friggin' years.
In brief chances with the Dodgers, Reyes hit .130, and came to be
considered as lazy and a poor handler of a pitching staff.
»
Dodger debut:
1983
»
Finally given up on:
1986
»
The low-down:
For a few years in the early- to mid-1980s, Fimple was high on the
Dodgers list of prospects. Fimple had a strong arm, but after batting
.226 over parts of a couple seasons and doing nothing else to distinguish
himself, the Dodgers let him go. Besides, there was a guy named
Gilberto Reyes who the Dodgers felt deserved the starting Triple-A
job.
»
Dodger debut:
1995
»
Finally given up on:
1999
»
The low-down:
Castro was the typical "good field, no hit" infielder.
He spent parts of five seasons with the Dodgers, and only got above
.200 oncein '95, when he had 11 at-bats. Castro is now with
the Reds, and flirted with .230 the past two seasonsproof
that the Dodgers gave up on him far too soon.
»
Dodger debut:
1990
»
Finally given up on:
1995
»
The low-down:
If Offerman hadn't homered in his first major league at-bat, maybe
the Dodgers would have given up on him sooner. But apparently his
offensive potential (which he never realized until after he left
the team) was enough to make the Dodgers overlook his horrendous
fielding skills. In just over 5 years, Offerman made 1,600 errors.
»
Dodger debut:
1982
»
Finally given up on:
1986
»
The low-down:
Showing outstanding power in the minor leagues, the Dodgers banked
on Greg Brock to be their starting first baseman and let Steve Garvey
go. However, Brock never could fill Garvey's shoes, and was finally
traded to Milwaukee for Tim Leary and Tim Crews... probably one
of the better deals the team has made.
»
Dodger debut:
1995
»
Finally given up on:
1998
»
The low-down:
Cedeno never really looked like he could play ball. Yet the Dodgers
stuck with him. Recently he's shown some of the talent the Dodgers
thought he had, just a little too late. Cedeno hit .251 with the
Dodgers, and .295 since then. Typical.
»
Dodger debut:
1986
»
Finally given up on:
1991
»
The low-down:
Whimpy Jeff somehow stuck around for 5 years. He's probably remembered
more for his inning of pitching than for his pathetic bat, never
managing to hit higher than .245. After the Dodgers let him go,
that was it. He never made it to the majors again.
»
Dodger debut:
1985
»
Finally given up on:
1989
»
The low-down:
The Dodgers tried Duncan at shortstop a number of times. He was
not good. Duncan was eventually traded to the Reds along with Tim
Leary for Lenny Harris and Kal Daniels.
»
Dodger debut:
1992
»
Finally given up on:
1997
»
The low-down:
Ashley was one of the longest Dodger projects in recent memory.
The monster of a man tore up the minors, but time after time floundered
when given a chance in L.A. He had a horrendous knowledge of the
strike zone and was a clumsy oaf in the outfield. He looked like
he'd be able to hit the shit out of the ball, but hit less home
runs as a Dodger than Dave Hansen. Ashley spent a year on the Red
Sox and is now used to block floodwater in Italy.
»
Dodger debut:
1996
»
Finally given up on:
1998
»
The low-down:
Wilton Guerrero was Alfredo Griffin minus the brain. Not that Griffin
was a genius, but Guerrero was a moron. (Who can forget the corked
bat incident.) Wilton managed to get an occasional hit or two,
and the Dodgers talked about him as if he'd be around for years
to come, but he completely lacked the baseball instincts necessary
to make it in the majors. Finally, he was dealt to the Expos along
with pitcher Ted Lilly and outfielder Peter Bergeron for Mark Grudzielanek,
Hiram Bocachica, and... Carlos Perez.
»
Dodger debut:
1982
»
Finally given up on:
1983
»
The low-down:
OK, Steve's younger brother was never a "can't miss" prospect...
in fact, he never got a hit as a Dodger, but we thought it would
be a nice gesture to recognize his sorry ass.
»
Dodger debut:
1997
»
Finally given up on:
1998
»
The low-down:
Paul Konerko was one of those "can't miss" prospects who
the Dodgers gave up on prematurely. True, they got Jeff Shaw for
him, but were the three years of Shaw worth Konerko's entire career?
The Dodgers never gave Konerko a chance, and of course he's proven
to be a solid major leaguer.
»
Dodger debut:
1989
»
Finally given up on:
1991
»
The low-down:
In
November of 1991 the Dodgers threw in the towel on 23-year-old John
Wetteland and traded him to the Reds along with Tim Belcher for
Eric Davis and pitcher Kip Gross. The Dodgers had no confidence
in Wetteland's control. So he went on to save 330 games229
of them with other teams.
»
Dodger debut:
1992
»
Finally given up on:
1993
»
The low-down:
Here's perhaps the most distressing case of the Dodgers completely
mis-evaluating talent. Pedro was brilliant working out of the bullpen
for the Dodgers in his first full season in 1993. He appeared in
a Dodger rookie-record 65 games, placing third among National League
rookies with 10 wins and 119 strikeouts. But the Dodgers, who needed
a second baseman and a leadoff hitter, felt that Pedro wasn't durable
enough to become a regular starter, so they sent Martinez to Montreal
for Delino DeShields. Lovely.
»
Dodger debut:
1987
»
Finally given up on:
1988
»
The low-down:
One of the jewels of the Dodgers minor league system, this guy pitched
more like a guy who had taken too many line drives in the family
jewels. Hillegas was 7-7 as a Dodger, and did no better on 4 other
teams, finally retiring in 1993.
»
Dodger debut:
1995
»
Finally given up on:
1997
»
The low-down:
Year after year we heard about Garcia's potential. Yet in bits of
3 seasons with the Dodgers, he hit .150, worse than Hideo Nomo.
Eventually Garcia was left unprotected in the '97 expansion draft
and ended up with Arizona.
»
Dodger debut:
1992
»
Finally given up on:
1995
»
The low-down:
Rodriguez was the typical Dodger prospect. They held onto him for
4 years and he sucked. So they let him go, and he hits 36 home runs
in his first season with the Expos.
»
Dodger debut:
N/A
»
Finally given up on:
1983
»
The low-down:
Franco was selected by the Dodgers in the fifth round of the 1981
amateur draft. He was never around long enough to become a "can't
miss" prospectand in fact never appeared for the Dodgersbut
he sure as hell flourished elsewhere. Since being traded to the
Reds for Raphael Landestoy in 1983, Franco has gone on save 422
games.
»
Dodger debut:
1984
»
Finally given up on:
1989
»
The low-down:
Stubbs' success in the minors was one of the reasons the Dodgers
were willing to part with Steve Garvey. As Greg Brock began to show
he was completely mediocre, the Dodgers gave Stubbs increased playing
time. And playing time. And playing time. But despite an '86 season
that saw him hit 23 home runs, Stubbs blew. He hit .194, .222, .226,
.233, .223, and finally .291 in an injury-plagued '89 season. Only
the Dodgers would stick with a guy so long.
»
Dodger debut:
1987
»
Finally given up on:
1991... oh wait, 1995
»
The low-down:
As he moved up in the Dodger minor league system, we were all told
that this guy was as good as his brother. Well, they were right
in one way: he was as good an eater as Tony. He never developed
into more than a pinch-hitter (partially because the Dodgers never
gave him much of a chance), and eventually signed with the Royals
in '92. He returned for the '94 and '95 seasons, but by that time
weighed about 340. Although that wasn't enough to stop him from
getting a key hit as a Padre to knock the Dodgers out of the race
at the end of '96.
>
Remember
someone we don't? If you know of a "can't miss"
Dodger prospect who we've forgotten, please let us know below.
|